Performance *** Recording ****
George Hall – BBC Music magazine – February 2021
“… The character roles are strongly etched, and I particularly loved Roxana Constantinescu and Martin-Jan Nijhof’s final exit duet as La Frugola and Talpa. The MDR Leipzig Radio Chorus makes a small but strong contribution. Whilst the orchestra plays finely for Marek Janowski, making a strong contribution to the recording, overall I found Janowski’s approach to tempos rather too steady, too sensible…”
Robert Hugill – Opera Today.com – January 2021
"... An outstanding release!"
ClassicalCDReview.com - December 2020
“… The baritone Lester Lynch is a vocally and dramatically accurate singer. Brian Jadge sings expressively with a confident tenor voice, and perfectly portrays the torn figure of Luigi. He shows the frustration of the extinguisher as well as the enthusiasm of the lover. At the end, I find the orchestra’s playing particularly interesting…” ****
Remy Franck - Pizzicato.lu – 15 December 2020
“… The American principals harness plenty of decibels. Brian Jagde has developed into quite a stentorian tenor, here as the rough-handed stevedore Luigi, and has the most Italianate tone of the three. Melody Moore sings a rich-voiced Giorgetta, successfully avoiding any hint of squalliness at the top. Lester Lynch is a crusty, effortful Michele …hurling his bruising baritone into the climax of his monologue ‘Nulla silenzio’. Among minor roles, Roxana Constantinescu is good as the chatterbox La Frugola …”
Mark Pullinger - Gramophone magazine - December 2020