*** Good Album

Performance *****      Recording ****

“… perfect technique, deep expression and unique vocal personalities combine in the singing of Scottish tenor Nicky Spence and Anglo-German contralto Claudia Huckle … there’s much to admire here in the mesh of voices and piano…”

Editor’s Choice – April 2023

“Stripped down Mahler reveals intimate exoskeleton beneath the behemoth.” ****½

“…Certainly, there’s plenty to admire in the performance, beginning with Nicky Spence’s ardent and sturdy performances of the tenor songs, distinguished by his usual highly engaged and engaging delivery…[Huckle's] voice is a superbly rich and seductive instrument with true contralto colour… this is a welcome recording that will, one hopes, bring a new audience to this rewarding version of this wonderful work.”

“… Nicky Spence … sings in full heldentenor voice throughout. Be that as it may, he’s quite excellent despite his stentorian, operatic approach, which might not seem so inappropriate in an orchestral setting.  Huckle’s intense and moving performance brings us far deeper into the emotional world of these songs, however. …  Her deep commitment shines through in every bar.  Equally splendid is the masterful pianism of the American conductor Justin Brown, who contributes an impressive tonal palette and sensitive dynamic shadings to the complex keyboard part.”

“… [Huckle] is perfectly suited, and has ideal musical companions in Spence, and in Brown, who helps you hear the orchestral colours in his playing. Das Lied, an impassioned if lopsided work, becomes more approachable on this scale – a good way in to a work that can seem overwhelming.”